A Coaching Cycle for Classroom Management: Agree, Observe, Try, Return

When a teacher asks for help with classroom management, it's easy to arrive with a long list. Too many observations, too many forms and too many things to fix. It can feel like an evaluation, even when it isn't one. I'd rather start smaller. One moment, one record, one change and a date to come back.

That's the cycle behind the classroom management section of the free Coaching Toolkit. It has four steps: agree, observe, try and return. Here is how I would use it.

Let the teacher choose the moment

Start with the teacher's priorities. You could ask a few plain questions. Which part of the period is hardest right now? What's already working that we should keep? What would you like me to watch for, and what would you rather I leave alone? Then choose one moment to improve and one successful routine to keep. That second part matters. It reminds both of you that something is already going well.

Before anyone records anything, agree on who can see the notes, where they will be stored and what has to be reported. If you also evaluate staff, say so plainly. And don't promise absolute confidentiality, because you may not be able to keep it. These records are meant to support learning and local decisions. They aren't a teacher evaluation tool.

Record what anyone could see

A useful record describes something another observer could see or hear, and could count or time. Write the action, not the motive. "A student asks where to find the task" is a record. "A student is avoiding the work" is a guess.

Say what you are counting, too. If ten of the 22 students you could see had started by the end of the cue, that's ten of 22, a little under half. It isn't ten out of everyone enrolled. Keep present, observed and absent students separate, and never enter a missed observation as a zero. If you track it over several visits, add up all the starts and divide by all the students observed. Don't average the daily percentages.

Try one change, and teach it

Pick one manageable change so the teacher can tell whether it was actually used. Then help the teacher teach it. Make the first step and the materials easy to find, show the action, and let students rehearse it with something low-stakes. Plan how a student rejoins if they miss the directions or lack what they need.

Check access before you add pressure. A direction students can't read, find or carry out is an access problem before it is a behavior problem. And listen to students. A private conversation that asks what part is hardest to get into will often tell you more than another observation.

Come back and compare

Put the return visit on the calendar before you leave the first one. When you return, record the same moment the same way, with the same definition, cue and time window, so you are comparing like with like.

First check what was implemented. Did the demonstration, the rehearsal and the supports actually happen? If they didn't, you can't judge how students responded. If they did and the concern is still there, adjust the plan together. Any target you set is a teacher-chosen aim for planning. It is not a benchmark and it isn't a rating of the teacher.

Here is how it plays out in the first fictional case in the toolkit. A Grade 9 English teacher, Renee, has a class where quiet entry works. But after the 9:12 start cue, many students wait while she repeats the first direction. She and her coach, Theo, choose one thing to count: how many students have begun a relevant first response 90 seconds after the cue. Over three visits, 27 of 65 recorded student checks had started, a little over 40 percent. In the notes, two students had asked which section to read. Renee had a slide with the whole assignment, but the passage and the first question were in different places.

Renee chooses one change. She makes the first step visible, shows students exactly where to begin, and has them try it once. Theo comes back for three more checks. This time 45 of 65 had started, about 69 percent, and the 70 percent aim Renee picked was met on two of the three days. Then comes the careful part. The numbers don't say which students changed, and the passage was a factor. So Renee keeps the routine another week, checks privately with students who are still struggling, and looks at the quality of their responses. Theo plans to return on October 28. All of the names and numbers are fictional.

Keep the record small

You don't need every form. A short planning conversation and a five-minute observation may be all a teacher needs. The toolkit has six management tools, five shared core forms, and three fictional cases with completed examples, so you can see what a finished record looks like without using real teachers or students. There is also a one-page teacher introduction with a thirty-minute team option, which is a gentler place to begin.

The four routines in Four Routines That Prevent Classroom Management Problems make good moments to choose. Starting class, getting unstuck, transitions and finishing early are all easy to define and easy to count. If you work with teachers, you could start there. Let me know how it goes at hello@polemountainlearning.com.

← All articles